0

Your Basket

Your Basket is Empty

Search

Feature - Issue #7

The Grammar of Being

Words by Anna Souter
Conceptual design and flower artistry by Alice McCabe
Featuring the work of Darren Appiagyei

How our use of language can define our relationship with the natural world.

How do we speak with plants? How do we talk of animals? How do we encounter nonhuman lives through our words? The language we use to talk about our ecosystems is both symptomatic of and contributes to how we perceive the more-than-human world.

The English language could be characterised by its ungenerosity towards nonhuman lives; a belief in the supremacy of the human is written into our grammar, inscribed on our tongues. English shuts out the agency of animals and plants, attributing personhood almost exclusively to human beings.

The difficulty lies primarily in the pronouns. In primatologist Jane Goodall’s first scientific paper, she referred to individual chimpanzees as “he” or “she” and used the relative pronoun “who”. Her editor sent it back to her after changing every “he” or “she” to “it” and every “who” to “which”. Goodall pushed back and, perhaps surprisingly, her original pronouns were allowed to stand. The anecdote nevertheless points to a widely held belief that using so-called “anthropomorphic” language about animals or plants is unscientific, imprecise, and even dangerous. The notion of “anthropomorphism” in language is in itself complex. Although some would disagree, it is arguably deeply arrogant to imply that animacy, gender, and consciousness are uniquely human traits; perhaps our experience of these things is a mere shadow of something practiced every day in the multiplicitous lives of plants and animals.

You can continue reading this, alongside all of the content from back issues, by becoming a digital subscriber.

FIND OUT MORE

Choose Your Own Leaf, Explore Related Pieces...

View All

Dialogue - Issue #13

Everything is Blindingly in Bloom

Words and illustration by Shana Cleveland

Dialogue - Issue #13

My Local Pond is Disappearing and I Can’t Stop Watching

Words by Diyora Shadijanova with illustration by Amelia Rouse

Feature - Issue #13

Rights and Responsibilities

Words by Sherri Mitchell

Feature - Issue #13

Radical Roots

Words by Kalpana Arias

Interview - Issue #13

Koji is Community

Interview by Josephine Marchandise with Pao-Yu Liu with photographs by David Reeve

Photography - Issue #13

Common Ground

Words by Vicky Chown and photography by William Hearle

Photography - Issue #13

Common Ground

Words by Vicky Chown and photography by William Hearle

Feature - Issue #13

Nature Rights

Words by Gregory and Koffman with photography by William Hearle

Feature - Issue #6

Feature - Issue #7